Happy with this for balancing costs, cruft and said in Backup Strategy Advice: This is my personal Cloudron setup now (rsync encrypted to Wasabi) + the 7 daily provider snapshots: So I think start with shorter intervals to get it all working confidently, then extend to longer intervals and don't store too old for the sake of it if you don't have some regulatory needs to. In my experience, no-one ever needs a backup past a week old, what is usually needed is the most recent recoverable. Their platforms, their rules, they can change at any time and you can be an accidental victim of bad actors in ways you'll never imagine before it happens.įrom what I understand storage boxes have hardware redundancy, so I don't think that would be a point of failure - most backup recovery needs are user or software caused. One of the biggest risks I see with anything nowadays isn't technical but Ts & Cs and provider lock-out. Certainly right to have a multi-provider & encrypted setup. This doesn't have the effect of conserving VPS resources, but should extend the backup range without adding to storage Sounds like a solid strategy to me. So I've sort off flipped that on it's head, and will try doing daily rysnc backups (retained for a week) and then weekly automatic snapshots on the Hetzner Storage Box (you get a certain number free, depending on storage capacity). In my case most of the app data is on an Netcup NFS mount, so snapshoting the server wouldn't be very useful (I doubt the addon storage is included). But I can understand that it's not priority at the moment (y'all are doing a great job with Your thinking on using the VPS snapshot does make a lot of sense. Even though there might be latency issues, I think this would be better than using a Netcup NFS mount, just so that the backups go to another provider from what the VPS is It would great if Cloudron could add more robust and nuanced backup options at some point. Others seem to be having trouble maintaining the mount with Hetzner Storage Boxes, so hopefully that doesn't happen too often. I've decided to try encrypted rsync to a Hetzner StorageBox via a CIFS mount. Thanks everyone for sharing your suggestions and insights (this is a very special community, and it's nice to be part of it). Would setting up a separate Minio backup server and using Rsync be a good solution? Ease of admin, cost, elasticity of storage to the actual size of the backups, and security would be the main considerations. Is there anything obvious I'm missing? How do you do backups? Any advice in getting this right would be much appreciated. I've played around with the memory and upload part size settings but still not luck, getting it stable. This worked OK a few times after increasing memory limits (up to over 6 GB), but I'm now getting task timeouts and am unable to successfully backup. This I guess is sub-optimal for having to transfer so much data every time (even though bandwidth is not at a premium or particularly limited). Then I switched to Backblaze, they don't charge for deleting data, but using rsync causes there to be a lot of API calls, with costs quickly adding up (though not as extremely as Wasabi). But Wasabi charge for deleting data, so even though the storage costs are very reasonable, the overall costs quickly become unreasonable. Initially, the backups were rsync to Wasabi. I would like to use a different service provider for backups (different vendor and geographic region) and also have have encryption enabled, so that the storage provider doesn't have to be trusted. Automatic backups are currently scheduled to run once a week, and the retention policy is set to one month (any opinions on whether this is to lax?). Some background info - backup size for the entire platfrom is currently about 850 GB, with most of the data being contributed to by user Nextcloud data. I have Cloudron installed on a Netcup VPS, and am having trouble setting up a reliable backup strategy that works on a consistently while being cost effective.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |